Our Carrier Partners
More Options.
Better Coverage.
As an independent agency, we’re not locked into any single insurance company. We work with 30+ top-rated carriers so we can always find the right program for your specific situation — not just the one we happen to sell.
What It Means to Be Independent
When you buy insurance from a captive agent — like a State Farm or Allstate exclusive — they can only offer you products from that one company. We’re different.
Not Tied to One Company
We represent you, not an insurer. Our job is to find the best coverage at the best price — wherever that happens to be. If a carrier raises their rates, we switch. You don’t have to.
We Shop for You
At every renewal, we review your coverage and re-shop the market. You don’t need to call around to a dozen companies — we do it for you, with access to carriers you can’t get directly.
Quality Over Price
Cheap coverage that doesn’t pay a claim isn’t worth anything. We work with financially strong, reputable carriers — companies with the ratings and track record to be there when you need them.
Companies We Work With
The following carriers represent a selection of the companies available through Green Bay Insurance Services. The right carrier for you depends on your coverage type, risk profile, and location — your agent will guide you to the best fit.
AAA
Acuity
American Collectors
American Modern
Berkley One
Burns & Wilcox
Chubb
Donegal
Foremost
GEICO
Germantown
Grange
Hagerty
Hanover
Hartford
Madison Mutual
Mt Morris
Old Republic Surety
Progressive / Progressive Home
Safeco
Secura
Sentry
Society
West Bend
Wisconsin MutualCarrier availability varies by coverage type and location. Not all carriers are available for all lines of business. Your agent will identify the best options for your specific situation.
How We Choose Carriers
Not all insurance companies are created equal. Here’s what we look for before we recommend a carrier to a client.
Financial Strength
We prioritize carriers with strong financial ratings so you can be confident they’ll be able to pay claims — even in a catastrophic loss year.
Claims Service
A carrier’s value is measured at claim time. We track how our carriers handle claims and only continue working with companies that treat policyholders fairly.
Wisconsin Expertise
We prefer carriers with deep Midwest and Wisconsin experience — underwriters who understand our weather, our industries, and the specific risks our clients face.
Let us shop the market for you.
Tell us what you need and we’ll come back with honest recommendations from the carriers that are the best fit for your situation.
Call (920) 301-7934